24 Hour Fitness Machines Top Weight 6 Keys to Self Publishing Success 9 Pioneers of Fitness Achieve High Fitness Levels Advice On Sports Nutrition Supplements Are Retirees Dummying Down Biologically Bench Press for Your Brain Cellular Nutrition Chemical and Biological Warfare Chemistry Nutritional Supplements Coaching Effective Teams Implement Experiential Learning Commitment To A Successful Fitness Create Your Author Platform Diet Nutrition and Healthy Living Dog Days Finding a Publisher Dramatically Increase Sales Conversion Education Based Marketing The New Sales Education Based Marketing Can Increase Sales Education vs Sales Based Marketing Fast Biologically Active Highly Fitness Franchise Fitness Trainer Five Questions Get Your Book Published Get and Stay Younger Looking and Slow Getting Your Book Published How to Find Health and Nutrition Hold the Press Penis Enlargement Actually Homeschool Curriculum Review Memoria Press How to Think About the Increasing Length Or Girth Which is Better Life Coaching Schools Make the Switch From Selling to Educating Names of African Children Born Atypically New Authors Publishing Options Nutrition Supplementation Nutritional Supplements Should On Writing for Publication Our Post Biological Evolution Boldly Part 3 The Road Portable Fitness Equipment Professional Services Win More Sales Put Power Behind Your Random House Book Publishing Self Publish Or Get a Mainstream Self Publishing Independent Publishing Traditional The Final Word On Fitness For Women The Many Hats of Self Published The New Face of Publishing The Present Situation For Writing The Real Deal How Useful The Ultimate Publishing Guide How to Publish To Publish Or To Self Too Much Power of the Press Traditional Publishing Self publishing and Subsidy Understanding Food Nutrition Labels What Are Music Publishers Why Join a Fitness Club Why Most Coaches Are the Gray Why You Should Consider Writing Childrens Books Get Published
10 Myths about Organ Donation 5 Benefits Of Worm Farming A-Z of Worm Farming All About Organic Food Answers to Some Important Questions Ask Your Doctor About Organic Everything You Need in Organic Facts About Organic Cosmetic Certification Facts About Worm Farming Getting To Know More About Organic Have You Ever Considered Worm Farming Home Panty Organization How To Use Worm Farm How To Worm Farm How to Make Worm Farm How to Set Up Worm Farm I Was Lied To About Organic Important Details About Worm Farming Important Facts About Organic Gardening Information You Should Know About Organic Interesting Facts About Organic Foods Keeping Earthworms Within A Farm Learn the Basics About Organic Look at the Reasons of Worm Farm Making a Worm Farm on Budget Marketing The Worm Farm More Faq About Organic One Harm to Worm Farm Organic Chicken Recipes Organic Gardening Can Make Hobby Quick and Simple Organic Grocery Skin Care Techniques Starting Worm Farms The Truth About Organic Beauty The Truths About Organic Anti The Ways to Go About Organic Things to Know About Worm Farm To Build Worm Farm Vermicomposting Recycling Idea Vermiculture Whats the Difference Among Worm What Can Vermiculture Do What Is Worm Composting What It Will Do For You What The Heck Is Organic What You Need to Know About Nutrition What You Should Know About Baby Foods What you to know about Vegetables Whats All The Buzz About Where The Worms Do The Work Organic Home Gardening Worm Farm History Worm Farming For Fun Worm Farming Secrets
Too Much Power of the PressSo shielded and privileged has the press become that a newspaper can falsely accuse a former public official of having taken a bribe ... and get away with it without penalty.
In an eye-opening decision May 17, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals dismissed a libel suit brought by Vincent R. Biskupic, who had been district attorney of Outagamie County from 1994 until January 2003. The decision upheld a lower court's ruling against Biskupic in a libel case he brought against the Shawano Leader for an article published in August 2004.
Moreover, it actually intensified the defeat ... the lower court had found that Biskupic was only a limited purpose public figure, since he no longer was in office when the article ran ... but the appeals court said no, he's a full public figure because of ongoing publicity about him ... that meant a slightly larger legal hurdle.
The article quoted Stacey Cicero, executive director of a domestic abuse prevention group, as saying Biskupic "was convicted of accepting bribes to dismiss cases."
Biskupic, while in office, had a policy of using payments to crime prevention groups and nonprofits as an alternative to criminal prosecution. He did not profit from the payments and was not affiliated with any organization that received them. He was investigated by an ethics board but not sanctioned.
Judges in that district later voted to halt the practice, and the Leader's article focused on that issue. Cicero's group had received such a payment. She went on to say, "Some of the money that defendants paid to have their cases dismissed went to organizations that he was involved in or into his own pocket."
The next day, the Leader ran a correction, and it ran another one in September in response to a demand letter from Biskupic. But off to court the matter went anyway. John C. Peterson, Biskupic's attorney, said he was especially troubled by the nature of the accusation ... bribery ... being leveled against a lawyer and former prosecutor, someone to whom integrity means so much.
Cicero, asked to explain, testified that she was quoted accurately but had gotten mixed up ... she had somehow confused Biskupic with Winnebago County District Attorney Joe Paulus, who was convicted of taking bribes in 2004. Cicero, in the article, mistakenly referred to Biskupic as being Winnebago County's DA, not Outagamie County's.
Biskupic had to show actual malice ... either knowledge the statements were false, or reckless disregard for the truth. He did not maintain that Cicero and the paper knew the statements were false, but there was reckless disregard in that, among other things, both Cicero and the reporter had plenty of time to check their facts but did not do so, and the paper hadn't bothered to interview Biskupic for his side of the story.
The court said no, this wasn't reckless disregard ... the mere fact of failure to verify information doesn't meet the legal standard ... and the reporter had no reason to question Cicero's motivation or ... incredibly ... the accuracy of her information.
The above facts come from an article by David Ziemer in the Wisconsin Law Journal.
Ziemer, in his case analysis, noted that "the reporter in this case could have conducted a Google search or visited the state courts or State Bar web sites and, in a matter of minutes, identified problems with Cicero's comment." He urged that the reckless disregard rule be re-examined in the light of modern technology. "Where the damage value of the false statements is extremely high, and the cost of verifying the truth of the statements is extremely low, a jury should be able to find reckless disregard for the truth."
It should also be noted that standard journalistic practice, from high school papers on up, requires reporters to check their facts and to give all relevant parties a chance to give their side of the story. If the failure to do so isn't "reckless disregard for the truth," it's hard to know what would be. The public is the poorer for not being able to be protected from shabby and perhaps dishonest journalism.
A second recent case also shows the public basically getting stomped on by the press. In this one, a federal appeals court in Richmond, Va., upheld the dismissal of a libel suit against the New York Times by Steven J. Hatfill, a former government scientist who specialized in biological weapons, and who had been identified by federal law enforcement officials as a "person of interest" in the investigation into the notorious anthrax mailings crime wave of 2001, which killed five people.
Cooper Publishing Group, LLC
P.O. Box 1129
Traverse City, Michigan 49685